Contents
Where to send criticisms, and criteria for publication
Please send criticisms of the principle to contact at koichi-takahashi dot me. As a rule, criticisms received are published in this list, each on its own page. Please send yours on that understanding, and say whether it should appear under your name or anonymously. What is published is exactly the text that the sender has approved, not a summary of it.
Koichi Takahashi decides what is published, according to the following criteria. Constitutive pluralism is set out in Chapter 11 of his book AGI: How Superhuman Intelligence Reshapes Civilization (in Japanese), in its supplementary essays, and in the paper. Criticisms of its claims, premises, or cases are published whether they support or oppose the principle. Criticisms of the book’s other claims are welcome at the same address and are handled separately as criticisms of the book. Criticisms judged to be unrelated to constitutive pluralism are not published, but if the sender publishes one elsewhere, a link to it will be added on request. Defamation, personal attacks, and texts that contain personal information about third parties are neither published nor linked.
Takahashi aims to respond to major objections but cannot promise a response to every submission.
List
No criticisms have been published yet.
First published: 9 November 2026. Last updated: 9 November 2026.